Italian chef loses pineapple pizza case — but not on the pizza

An Italian chef sacked by a Brisbane restaurant after refusing to put pineapple on a customer’s pizza has lost his bid to challenge the dismissal. Despite the headlines, though, Australia’s workplace tribunal never actually ruled on the pizza.

Davide Tamburella, who cooked at La Costa in Fortitude Valley, told the Fair Work Commission that the topping was an insult to his culture. The commission threw out his unfair dismissal claim this week, but only because he had lodged it too late.

A chef’s floured hands pressing a ball of pizza dough on a marble counter in a commercial kitchen.
The Fair Work Commission dismissed the pineapple pizza case because the chef’s claim was lodged too late, not over the topping. (Image: La Costa Restaurant)

A birthday order gone wrong

The row started with a birthday. A customer celebrating at the restaurant asked for pineapple on their pizza, an utterly ordinary request in Australia, where ham and pineapple is a fixture on takeaway menus. Tamburella refused.

It wasn’t the first time. The commission’s ruling notes this was the third time in four years he had turned down the same instruction. Called in to discuss performance concerns, he reportedly urged his boss to find out just how much it matters to Italians that pineapple stays off pizza.

About a fortnight later, on 20 May, he was let go. The pineapple was not the only grievance on the list: the ruling also cites inappropriate language he admitted to using, and ongoing concerns about his leadership and professionalism.

Lost on a deadline, not a topping

This is the bit much of the coverage glossed over. Workers in Australia have 21 days from the date of dismissal to lodge an unfair dismissal claim. Tamburella missed that window, and the commission found no exceptional circumstances that would justify giving him extra time.

The commission also heard that he had hurt his right hand at work, fracturing two bones after striking a metal handrail. But the late application decided the matter.

So the commission never weighed up whether a chef can refuse an order on cultural grounds, or whether the sacking itself was fair. The case ended on procedure alone.

“We’re not in Italy”

La Costa boss Elliot Ingram has since said on social media that the pineapple was not the one thing that sealed the chef’s fate. In his telling, it played a part, but the bigger issues were building up behind the scenes.

He accepts that Italians tend to be traditional about their food, pizza most of all.

He said:

“But at the end of the day we’re not in Italy, we’re in Australia,”

It’s a debate older than the restaurant itself: the Hawaiian pizza was dreamt up not in Hawaii or Naples but in Canada, in the 1960s, and it has divided diners ever since. La Costa has now closed, and Tamburella has reportedly found work at another Italian restaurant in Brisbane — one where, for now at least, pineapple pizza isn’t on the menu.

More from the valley: Charter Hall buys Fortitude Valley corner site for AFP’s new Northern Command centre


Source: ABC 

Scroll to Top